Fundamentals of dosimetry
Course of Viktor Olegovich Sergeev
Methodological manuals:
Brief course programme - download
Additional materials
Radiation dose from X-rays, CT, MRI and ultrasound: well, how much is too much?
| Overview |
| Recording radiation doses |
| Which examination is the most dangerous? |
| What is the permissible radiation dose in medical examinations? |
Overview
The effect of radiation on the body
Of all the radiation methods of diagnosis only three: X-ray (including fluorography),
scintigraphy and computed tomography, are potentially associated with
dangerous radiation — ionizing radiation.
X-rays are capable of splitting molecules into their constituent
parts, therefore under their action the destruction of the membranes
of living cells, as well as damage to the nucleic acids DNA and RNA, is possible.
Thus, the harmful effect of hard X-ray radiation
is associated with the destruction of cells and their death, as well as damage to
the genetic code and mutations. In ordinary cells mutations over
time may become the cause of a cancerous degeneration, and in
germ cells — they increase the probability of deformities in the future generation.
The harmful effect of such types of diagnosis as MRI and ultrasound has not been proven.
Magnetic resonance imaging is based on the emission of electromagnetic
waves, while ultrasound examinations are based on the emission of mechanical
vibrations. Neither the one nor the other is associated with ionizing radiation.
Ionizing irradiation is especially dangerous for the tissues of the body that
are intensively renewed or grow. Therefore the first to suffer from radiation are:
- the bone marrow, where the formation of the cells of immunity and blood takes place
- the skin and mucous membranes, including those of the gastrointestinal tract
- the tissues of the foetus in a pregnant woman
Children of all ages are especially sensitive to irradiation, since
their level of metabolism and the rate of cell division are far
higher than in adults. Children are constantly growing, which makes them vulnerable
to radiation.
At the same time, X-ray methods of diagnosis:
fluorography, radiography, fluoroscopy, scintigraphy and
computed tomography are widely used in medicine. Some
of us expose ourselves to the rays of an X-ray machine on our
own initiative: so as not to miss something important and
to detect an invisible disease at the earliest stage.
But most often
it is a doctor who sends one for radiation diagnostics. For example,
you come to a polyclinic to get a referral
for a health-improving massage or a certificate for the swimming pool,
and the therapist sends you for a fluorography. One asks,
why this risk? Can the "harmfulness"
of an X-ray be measured somehow and compared with the necessity of such an examination?
Recording radiation doses
By law, every diagnostic examination associated with X-ray irradiation must be recorded in the radiation dose accounting sheet, which the radiologist fills in and pastes into your outpatient card. If you are examined in a hospital, the doctor must transfer these figures to the discharge summary.
In practice hardly anyone observes this law. At best you will be able to find the dose with which you were irradiated in the conclusion to the examination. At worst — you will never find out at all how much energy you received with the invisible rays. However, it is your full right to demand from the radiologist information about what the "effective radiation dose" amounted to — that is exactly what the indicator by which the harm from an X-ray is assessed is called. The effective radiation dose is measured in milli- or microsieverts — abbreviated "mSv" or "µSv".
Previously radiation doses were assessed using special tables where averaged figures were given. Now every modern X-ray machine or computed tomograph has a built-in dosimeter which immediately after the examination shows the number of sieverts you have received.
The radiation dose depends on many factors: the area of the body that was irradiated, the hardness of the X-rays, the distance to the X-ray tube and, finally, the technical characteristics of the machine itself on which the examination was performed. The effective dose received during an examination of the same area of the body, for example the chest, can change by a factor of two or more, therefore after the fact one can calculate how much radiation you received only approximately. It is better to find this out at once, without leaving the room.
Which examination is the most dangerous?
To compare the "harmfulness" of various types of X-ray diagnostics one can use the average values of effective doses given in the table. These are data from methodological recommendations No. 0100/1659-07-26 approved by Rospotrebnadzor in 2007. Every year the equipment is improved and the dose load during examinations can be gradually reduced. It is possible that in clinics equipped with the newest machines you will receive a smaller radiation dose.
| Body part, organ | Dose, mSv/procedure | |
|---|---|---|
| film | digital | |
| Fluorograms | ||
| Chest | 0,5 | 0,05 |
| Limbs | 0,01 | 0,01 |
| Cervical spine | 0,3 | 0,03 |
| Thoracic spine | 0,4 | 0,04 |
| Lumbar spine | 1,0 | 0,1 |
| Pelvic organs, hip | 2,5 | 0,3 |
| Ribs and sternum | 1,3 | 0,1 |
| Radiographs | ||
| Chest | 0,3 | 0,03 |
| Limbs | 0,01 | 0,01 |
| Cervical spine | 0,2 | 0,03 |
| Thoracic spine | 0,5 | 0,06 |
| Lumbar spine | 0,7 | 0,08 |
| Pelvic organs, hip | 0,9 | 0,1 |
| Ribs and sternum | 0,8 | 0,1 |
| Oesophagus, stomach | 0,8 | 0,1 |
| Intestine | 1,6 | 0,2 |
| Head | 0,1 | 0,04 |
| Teeth, jaw | 0,04 | 0,02 |
| Kidneys | 0,6 | 0,1 |
| Mammary gland | 0,1 | 0,05 |
| Fluoroscopies | ||
| Chest | 3,3 | |
| GIT | 20 | |
| Oesophagus, stomach | 3,5 | |
| Intestine | 12 | |
| Computed tomography (CT) | ||
| Chest | 11 | |
| Limbs | 0,1 | |
| Cervical spine | 5,0 | |
| Thoracic spine | 5,0 | |
| Lumbar spine | 5,4 | |
| Pelvic organs, hip | 9,5 | |
| GIT | 14 | |
| Head | 2,0 | |
| Teeth, jaw | 0,05 | |
It is obvious that the highest radiation
load can be received when undergoing fluoroscopy
and computed tomography. In the first case this is associated with the duration
of the examination.
Fluoroscopy is usually carried out for several minutes, while an X-ray
image is taken in fractions of a second. Therefore during a dynamic examination
you are irradiated more strongly.
Computed tomography involves a series of images: the more slices — the higher the load, this is the price for the high quality of the resulting picture. The radiation dose is even higher in scintigraphy, since radioactive elements are introduced into the body. You can read in more detail about how fluorography, radiography and other radiation methods of examination differ.
To reduce the potential harm from radiation examinations, there are means of protection. These are heavy lead aprons, collars and plates, with which the doctor or laboratory assistant must certainly provide you before the diagnosis. The risk from an X-ray or computed tomography can also be reduced by spacing the examinations as far apart in time as possible. The effect of irradiation can accumulate and the body has to be given time to recover. Trying to undergo a diagnosis of the whole body in one day is unwise.
How to remove radiation after an X-ray?
An ordinary X-ray is an exposure of the body to gamma radiation, that is, to high-energy electromagnetic vibrations. As soon as the machine is switched off, the exposure stops, the irradiation itself does not accumulate and does not collect in the body, therefore there is nothing to remove either. But in scintigraphy radioactive elements are introduced into the body, and they are the emitters of the waves. After the procedure it is usually recommended to drink more liquid in order to get rid of the radiation sooner.
What is the permissible dose of radiation in medical examinations?
How many times can one have a fluorography, an X-ray or a CT scan so as not to cause harm to health? There is an opinion that all these examinations are safe. On the other hand, they are not carried out on pregnant women and children. How to sort out what is true and what is a myth?
It turns out that a permissible radiation dose for a person during medical diagnostics does not exist even in the official documents of the Ministry of Health. The number of sieverts is subject to strict accounting only for the staff of X-ray rooms, who are irradiated day after day together with the patients, despite all measures of protection. For them the average annual load must not exceed 20 mSv, in individual years the radiation dose may amount to 50 mSv, as an exception. But even exceeding this threshold does not mean that the doctor will start glowing in the dark or that horns will grow on him because of mutations. No, 20–50 mSv is only the boundary beyond which the risk of the harmful effect of radiation on a person increases. The dangers of average annual doses below this value could not be confirmed over many years of observations and research. At the same time, it is known purely theoretically that children and pregnant women are more vulnerable to X-rays. Therefore they are recommended to avoid irradiation just in case, all examinations associated with X-ray radiation are carried out on them only for vital indications.
Dangerous radiation dose
The dose beyond which radiation sickness begins — damage to the body under the action of radiation — amounts to from 3 Sv for a person. It is more than 100 times higher than the permissible average annual one for radiologists, and it is simply impossible for an ordinary person to receive it during medical diagnostics.
There is an order of the Ministry of Health which introduces restrictions on the radiation dose for healthy people during preventive examinations — this is 1 mSv per year. This usually includes such types of diagnostics as fluorography and mammography. In addition, it is stated that it is forbidden to resort to X-ray diagnostics for prophylaxis in pregnant women and children, and it is also forbidden to use fluoroscopy and scintigraphy as a preventive examination, as the most "heavy" in terms of irradiation.
The number of X-ray images and tomograms must be limited by the principle of strict reasonableness. That is, an examination is necessary only in those cases when refusing it will cause greater harm than the procedure itself. For example, in inflammation of the lungs one has to take a radiograph of the chest every 7–10 days until complete recovery, in order to track the effect of antibiotics. If we are talking about a complex fracture, the examination may be repeated even more often, in order to make sure that the bone fragments are correctly aligned and a callus forms, etc.
Is there any benefit from radiation?
It is known that in the home a natural radiation background acts on a person. This is, first of all, the energy of the sun, as well as radiation from the bowels of the earth, architectural structures and other objects. The complete exclusion of the action of ionizing radiation on living organisms leads to a slowing down of cell division and early ageing. And conversely, small doses of radiation have a general strengthening and therapeutic effect. The effect of the well-known resort procedure — radon baths — is based on this.
On average a person receives about 2–3 mSv of natural radiation per year. For comparison, with digital fluorography you will receive a dose equivalent to natural irradiation over 7–8 days in a year. And, for example, a flight by aeroplane gives on average 0.002 mSv per hour, plus the operation of a scanner in the security check area 0.001 mSv per one pass, which is equivalent to the dose over 2 days of ordinary life under the sun.
Article author: Andrei Olegovich